Tuesday, July 1, 2008

The Mothman Prophecies (2002)

Remember Laura Linney? The magnificent Laura Linney? Well, evidently she needs good material to work with in order to be magnificent. That’s where Mothman Prophecies fails.

Reporter John Klein (Richard Gere) endures the loss of his wife Mary (Debra Messing, who I love) after a car accident. After her death, he discovers a notebook filled with strange drawings of a monster. The story picks up two years later when he arrives at Point Pleasant. Local reports of strange incidents and sightings leads him to face what may have caused his wife’s death years ago.

I have always had a fascination with urban legends. Based on a book of the same title, the movie was supposed to depict the real documented events that surrounded the town in the 1960’s. Instead, the film takes a more personal tone by focusing on the characters rather than the mystery of the Mothman. While character development is a must-have in movies for me, the Mothman is shunted to the side even though it is the hook of the film. Even worse, it is then turned into a prophetic entity that foreshadow disasters. There’s nothing remotely scary or chilling about the Mothman in this movie. Silly is a better description.

What did surprise me was the direction by Mark Pellington, which I found to be skilled and rightfully unnerving. But despite his best attempts to enhance the creepiness, cheesy effects and awful dialogue manage to ruin the mood entirely. The only part that was remotely thrilling was the last twenty minutes, where the surprisingly elaborate action sequence took the film to its climax. It does so, however, while leaving behind several plot holes.

Despite having an interesting concept and an adequate cast, you cannot explain an entire story with the notion that “there are entities that are beyond physical reality.” It’s cheap and makes me want to hurt myself. The Moth Prophecies is yet another cautionary example that shows just because a film is based on true events doesn’t mean it's good.

C-

No comments: