Friday, July 4, 2008

The Golden Compass (2007)

I have to admit, the film industry is getting out of control with remake after remake. Unfortunately, it seems another current trend is taking good novels and making film adaptations. This tactic is effective in drawing in the younger audiences, especially those who have heard of or read the novels first. However, this doesn’t mean that every said film will become as successful as Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings. The Golden Compass is a perfect example of that.

Lyra Belacqua is a rebellious girl living in an alternate universe that is parallel to ours. As an orphan living at the Magisterium, she has seen more than her share of secrecy that the big wigs does not want getting out. One day she hears a discussion about what is called “Dust” as possible evidence that other worlds exist. Not long after, she is given the golden compass for safe keeping as she embarks on a journey with the mysterious Ms. Coulter (Nicole Kidman).

OK, this summary doesn’t cover half of what the story entails, but the author Phillip Pullman has created such a rich and dynamic world with its own unique rules that it would take a few pages to do it justice. Visually, the movie is a great medium to express Pullman’s vision. With the special effects that we’re capable today, the movie’s illustration of the other-world was top notch. I was delighted to see what I have imagined years ago come to life.

Despite its success on the visual side, the film is confused as to the tone of the story it’s trying to tell. The Golden Compass, for me, never felt like a story that would transition well into film. Despite its fantasy-based world, the trilogy is much more about the characters than anything else. The film version tried to make it into an action-oriented fantasy story where the main characters received little character development.

In addition, the film felt rushed trying to include every important detail when in fact the world is far too rich to be properly portrayed in a two hour movie. Pullman's vision is a combination of the realism and structure of our world with his own fantasy world. Had I not read the book first, I would've only followed the images with confusion.

Perhaps the worst part is the great waste of the amazing actors that were hired to portray the characters. Left with little to work with and nothing to do but look serious in front of a green screen, an indie version of this would’ve worked better than the empty spectacle the film presents.

C

No comments: