August Rush is the quintessential feel-good movie with a mixture of romance and fantasy. After cellist Lyla (Keri Russell) and Louis (Jonathan Rhys Meyers) spend one soul-changing night together, they are broken apart by personal obligations. Soon after, Lyla gives birth to a boy which her father sends to an orphanage without her knowing. This boy, soon to be known as August Rush, will embark on a journey to find his parents, all with a little thing called music as the connection between them all.
The central tie between all the characters is their love and faith in music. I found the idea to be very relatable. To my dismay, music has been turned into something that seems to possess magical and telepathic powers. The music motif has been done before, but this movie takes it far beyond the realm of believability. And on a personal note, I cannot stand music related movies that get the music part wrong. I get completely disconnected when the music recording does not match the action. News flash, the notes get higher when you move up the keyboard. The movie also explains Rush’s affinity with music by branding him a musical prodigy. I’m sorry, even prodigies cannot simply fidget with an organ and learn all the stops and footwork. Prodigies have to learn first, they’re not born with the knowledge of the workings of every instrument. Finally, you need to learn how musical notations work before writing it. Somehow August Rush has internally stored all the notations at birth. August Rush does not learn before he is good. That makes him cheap and unrealistic. AND August Rush’s final composition is not original work. He took the theme from Bach. Hm…well it sounds good, but it’s not because of him.
OK, my rant is over.
The performances by the actors are all adequate, but the script is too lackluster on the dialogue side to really work. The story’s happy ending is also too spectacular for me to really believe in the struggle the characters went through. Julliard? Seriously? Child conductor? Seriously?
Like I said, I love movies like this, but August Rush is simply too good to be true, or believable.
C

No comments:
Post a Comment