
Every once in a while there comes a film that has a bit of a hidden agenda. When Charlie Bartlett was first advertised, the first thing I noticed was that it was about a high school student selling prescription medication to other students. OK…
My first instinct was to give it a chance, because I often enjoy edgy or controversial films, and this one is definitely leading with one hell of a topic. Turns out, this is a film that is really a feel-good film in disguise.
Charlie Bartlett is a 17 year old who’s gotten expelled from pretty much every private school he’s ever been to due to his overwhelmingly childish urge to be popular, thus leading him to various illegal activities. His mother doesn’t help the matter by letting him get away with his misdemeanors, eventually deciding to transfer him to a public high school. After getting beat up, his mother immediately has her on-call psychiatrist diagnose him with ADD and prescribes him with Ritalin. This is where he decides to sell various medications that he could obtain to the high school population and give out therapy sessions in the boy’s bathroom.

Now, I don’t mind controversy when the writer is trying to be earnest or uncomfortably illuminating. Juno, a teenage quirk comedy that came out around the time of this film managed to tread over several controversial issues without making us feel uneasy. This film tries a similar tactic by introducing psychiatry (which is pretty much made out to be drug dealers in this movie), illegal distribution of medication, teenage bullying, sexual promiscuity, vandalism, suicide and various sordid activities that teenagers might get involved with. After introducing some shocking facets of Bartlett’s high school, the second half is more about redeeming what the first half points out and ends on a hopeful note. Normally, this tactic works because we can relate to the journey of the characters, but this film made me feel as if the characters got away with everything with too little of consequence. Certain instances like when Bartlett sells DVDs of classmates getting beat up, feels outrightly wrong, but the film justifies it as a phase that comes from teenagers not being heard. Quite simply, it feels cheap.
On a brighter note, the film features the best younger cast since 10 Things I Hate About You. Charlie Bartlett might as well be Juno's distant cousin, as they both retain the quirky non-chalant attitude of someone completely self-aware yet doesn't care. It's hard not to like him, but his actions make him right on the edge for me, even when he turns a new leaf.
The film also tries to have an air of ease around serious situations (Grey’s Anatomy comes to mind), but certain instances, like when the principal points a gun at Charlie, seems way too serious for the characters to realistically let go so quickly. I find it nice to introduce characters who can let go and move on, but in this case it felt completely disjointed that they made up five minutes later.
I appreciate the film’s message of universality through differences, and there are a lot of tender yet surprising moments. But the film tries to bridge the gap between controversial and hopeful, and feels slightly bumpy as a result.
If it wasn’t for Juno, this might be one of the better teenage coming-of-age tales in the last few years, but alas, in terms of execution and sentiment Juno is ahead of Charlie Bartlett by a long mile.
B